The Hostetter Team at CENTURY 21 Scheetz is where passion for real estate meets a genuine love for Downtown Indianapolis living. Led by the dynamic Dylan Hostetter, this team is not just connected; they embody the essence of loving where they live.

Dylan Hostetter is more than a real estate professional; he’s your new best friend in the business. His outgoing and friendly approach to life seamlessly integrates into his real estate endeavors, making every buying, selling, or investing experience enjoyable and stress-free. With Dylan, it’s not just about transactions; it’s about building lasting relationships. His commitment to clear communication, innovative real estate systems, and efficient processes ensures that every client is well-informed, empowering them to make the best decisions for a successful personal or business transaction.

Meet Sarah Grain, a dedicated member of The Hostetter Team. With Sarah, you’re not just in good hands; you’re in the hands of a meticulous and thorough professional. Sarah’s excellence as a communicator shines through as she takes the time to truly understand her clients’ needs and wants. Her empathetic approach to aligning these aspirations with real estate goals is nothing short of remarkable. When it comes to making one of the biggest financial decisions of your life, having Sarah in your corner is an invaluable asset.

Kat Reiner, Business Manager, supports The Hostetter Team with Operations and Marketing. She has a keen eye for systems and processes that help run a professionally astute Real Estate business.

Ranked among the top and most respected teams in the Indianapolis area, the Hostetter Team is synonymous with professionalism and excellence. Whether you’re a first-time homebuyer, seasoned investor, or looking to sell your property, entrust The Hostetter Team to guide you through every step of the real estate journey. Their expertise, passion, and commitment to client satisfaction make them the ideal choice for all your real estate needs. Let The Hostetter Team turn your real estate dreams into reality.

Our Team



Dylan, a dedicated Real Estate Broker in Metropolitan Indianapolis, is a master at building lasting relationships. His upbringing near Downtown Indy instilled a profound love for urban environments. Having previously thrived in California’s entertainment industry, Dylan toured with Chanticleer and worked as a wardrobe stylist.

Returning in 2018, he rekindled his enthusiasm for downtown living. Recognized for his servant’s heart, Dylan stands as one of the most trusted Real Estate Professionals, ensuring that home transactions are an enjoyable experience for each client. Beyond real estate, he immerses himself in music, hones his culinary skills, embraces yoga, and relishes precious moments with his remarkable family.


Business Manager

Kat oversees operations and marketing for the Hostetter Team. She and Dylan love raising their family on Indy’s near east side. They stay active in the community through volunteer work and supporting their favorite small local businesses.



Sarah, a proud Hoosier from the northside of Indianapolis, is a dynamic force in the city’s arts and music scene. A graduate of Indiana University with a degree in Urban Studies, she has seamlessly merged her passions for real estate with her creative spirit.

As a dedicated Real Estate Broker, Sarah focuses on Downtown Indianapolis, where her clients appreciate her empathetic and masterful communication style. She goes beyond transitions, understanding and guiding them through every step of the process.

Beyond real estate, Sarah is a singer-songwriter leading the 5-piece band, Sarah Grain & the Billons of Stars. Her creative endeavors span over two decades, producing full-length albums and gracing venues with her music all around town.

Family is central to Sarah’s life, with her husband Tedd, three children, and furry companions. She thrives not only in crafting beautiful spaces in real estate but also in creating harmonious melodies that resonate with her audience. Sarah is more than a Real Estate Broker; she’s a storyteller, enriching lives through the narratives of home and music.